Are teachers a disappearing profession… ?

 

I think there is an underlying fear that the internet or computers will one day replace our beloved profession… but is it likely to come true?

 

 

I can’t see it happening and here’s why. Interested to hear what you think ;-)

 

An evolution

Yes, maybe Teacher Version 0.5 is disappearing- the teacher that simply lectures from notes dusty with age.  Their disappearance comes as we notice an evolution towards…

teacher 2.0

A teacher that masterfully uses all of the tools at their and their students’ disposition to increase collaborative learning. A teacher who mixes pedagogy, soft skills and tech skills, encouraging synchronous and asynchronous learning be it in a physical or digital environment, and doing it in a way that really drives learning and not rote repetition or completion of exercises.

 

A missing ingredient

Online learning is certainly exploding (nearly doubling over the next 5 years) , and other great bloggers in the community (phil, david) have questioned its future style as they have even questioned the existence of physical classrooms a decade from now.

And yet many online learning tools are still missing a key ingredient: a coach who is present. I know, I know… such a buzz word these days, and I agree: funny that coach has become synonymous for “language teacher”, especially in the 1to1 corporate environment. And yet, it’s true, and it’s definitely moving in the direction of teachers as mentioned in point one— a collaborative approach helping develop specific skills that challenge specific learners or groups of learners.

It’s for this reason, believe it or not, that elearning is still not working very well in many contexts; usage rates of many e-learning applications are quite low with even less than 5% of students taking advantage of what schools offer them for blended learning (thankfully not ours!).

Why?

Intrinsic motivation. Often it’s because the applications are not engaging (something Phil mentions in his post above, and also something we’ve worked very hard and have been successful in improving with English Addicts and our other online lessons).

Extrinsic motivation. While I’m the last person to subscribe to the philosophy that teachers carry a stick and say “do”, or dangle a “carrot” in front of students saying “follow”, there is most certainly a huge impact when we work towards something collaboratively, and when students work on something with a “coach” behind their efforts, noticing where and when to help them.

This is why Edulang has specifically designed its applications with teachers in mind- providing student-tracking, and ways for teachers to globally understand how to help their students.  Along these lines, an interesting article in Wired yesterday quoted Jonhatan Yve speaking about Apple’s design philosophy which follows ours quite closely:

“Our products are tools and we don’t want design to get in the way.

We’re trying to bring simplicity and clarity”.

 

Change… always change, but always a community behind that change.

Just as I described the evolution of teachers that we’re seeing these days, so is there an evolution in learning strategies, learning environments, learning platforms, learning materials, teaching approaches, teaching certification… and on and on.  Who understands that evolution and follows it?  The great influencers of our industry, and the teachers who enjoy continuing with their professional development.

The skills each new evolution will require will change just as each element within the environment will change along with it, however, there will always be a place for leaders who understand these changes, who care about the learners and who are truly present in a way a machine cannot be.

… my two cents …

 

Whaddya think?


Related posts:

About Brad

--- i'm a learner-teacher, language geek, outdoorsy kind-of-guy --- U might miss the next tweet... Wanna subscribe by email ? ;-)
 
  • http://www.facebook.com/James.P.OReilly James OReilly

    How many Sustainable & Accountable Jobs Created is #Eltons good for? On this 8 yr graph ow.ly/b7dv2

  • http://blog.edulang.com/ Brad Patterson

    Hey James.  Thanks for stopping by and sharing your thoughts.

    Google trends is indeed a fascinating tool… though I’m not sure to what extent we can really rely on its analyses.  For example, it would seem that “computers” are on the decline too:

    http://www.google.de/trends/?q=computer&ctab=0&geo=all&date=all&sort=0

    (and I checked just out of curiosity and luckily “love” is on the rise)  ;-)

    Otherwise, most market research I’ve seen shows the language industry (especially TESOL) is growing very steadily:

    http://www.euractiv.com/culture/eu-language-industry-worth-84bn-euros/article-187814
    http://www.ibisworld.com.au/industry/default.aspx?indid=590

    Cheers 4 the dialogue. -Brad

  • EvaBanu

    I love the way teacher 2.0 is defined:)

  • http://juandomingofarnos.wordpress.com/2012/05/25/are-teachers-a-disappearing-profession-via-shellterrell-brad5patterson/ Are teachers a disappearing profession… ? via @shellterrell @brad5patterson « juandon. Innovación y conocimiento

    [...] on http://www.edulang.com Valora esto:Me gusta:Me gustaSé el primero en decir que te gusta esta post. [...]

  • http://blog.edulang.com/ Brad Patterson

    cheers, Eva! ;-)

  • Phil Wade

    Hi Brad,

    Great post, as always.

    I asked a student in a speaking exam today about his experience of online learning and he said he still preferred F2F. However, he admitted to using FB and messenger when he was supposed to be in webinars and I very much doubt he did any with his web cam. This really shows how you have to jump in and really go for it. It’s easy to stand aside and say “well, people are just chatting in the comments” or “the teacher is just talking on the screen”. But if you get involved you see how much interaction there is. Just look at BESIG (via Mike TECH GURU Hogan) webinars. There you have the actual presentation but also loads of stuff going on in the comments which then feeds into the webinar presenter’s talk.

  • John Thompson

    Isaac Azimov: Any teacher that can be replaced by a computer should be.

  • http://blog.edulang.com/ Brad Patterson

    Brilliant perspective which says quite a bit in one tiny sentence.  Thanks John.

  • Jason Levine

    Brad, wonderful piece that is sure to spur a lively discussion thread. Here is where I am regarding the “community behind that change.”

    In the future, there will be two types of teachers: The creators and the facilitators. The creators will create content for the classroom or magic in their lessons-or both. They will reach millions of learners through their counterparts, the facilitators, who will integrate and deliver this content via digital media. This will take place in both virtual and traditional classrooms. The traditional classroom will be transformed into an exciting, multi-sensory space for learners to experience the work of multiple creators. Learners will communicate fluidly with one another around the world through social platforms. Uninspired teachers will be a thing of the past; inferior teaching will cease to exist. A bad teacher will have as much chance finding work as a bad actor has now of getting a role in a major motion picture or a mediocre basketball player has of going pro. The pertinent question will no longer be “How could online learning possibly replace the classroom experience?” but rather “How could people have ever accepted learning from one person in one group of students in one room with the door closed to the rest of the world?”
     
     

  • http://blog.edulang.com/ Brad Patterson

    Yes.  The trick being the difference between a typical online language virtual environment, and a group of motivated teachers joining for professional development with a leader in the industry.  Still boils down to motivation, and still brings up the same questions that challenge us every single time we plan a lesson— how do we get their attention, maintain it, and develop positively through it… 

  • Sylvie_guinan

    I think I’m evolving;)

    We had a great discussion on facebook about similar topics – let me find a quote!!

  • Sylvie_guinan

    I referred to this phenomena the other day as a natural evolution in education. Here’s what Fluency MC ( Jason R Levine) said…

    “On the topic of ‘natural evolution’ here are my two cents. In the future, there will be two types of teachers: The creators and the facilitators. The creators will create content for the classroom or magic in their lessons-or both.

     They will reach millions of learners through their counterparts, the facilitators, who will integrate and deliver this content via digital media. This will take place in both virtual and traditional classrooms. The traditional classroom will be transformed into a space for learners to experience the work of multiple creators.

     Learners will communicate fluidly with one another around the world through social platforms. Uninspired teachers will be a thing of the past; inferior teaching will cease to exist. A bad teacher will have as much chance finding work as a bad actor has now of getting a role in a major motion picture or a mediocre basketball player has of going pro. The pertinent question will no longer be “How could online learning possibly replace the classroom experience?” but rather “How could people have ever accepted learning from one person in one group of students in one room with the door closed to the rest of the world”Virtual classrooms now have ‘break out’ rooms too – fantastic opportunites for guessing games, team work, collaborating – lots of things you mentioned above Brad….

    Also comic sites where students make their own comics etc….and posters…true blended learning, so much fun and so motivating…..Utopic or already happening….??Must get back to work now – I am preparing gramster and vocabster for my student:)
    Utopic or already happening….??Must get back to work now – I am preparing gramster and vocabster for my student:)

  • http://www.scoop.it/t/tic-gff/p/1841564751/are-teachers-a-disappearing-profession Are teachers a disappearing profession… ? | TIC_gff | Scoop.it

    [...] background-position: 50% 0px ; background-color:#062342; background-repeat : no-repeat; } http://www.edulang.com – Today, 5:39 [...]

  • Raquel

    We cannot deny the fact that the presence of real teachers impacted most of students’ learning.
    I know this because I was a student and now an online English teacher. I saw the difference..

  • Jason Levine

    It’s SKILLvia and Fluency SYNERGY at work once again!

  • http://blog.edulang.com/ Brad Patterson

    A fine duo it is ;-)  Bon weekend, guys!!!!

  • http://blog.edulang.com/ Brad Patterson

    Real teachers that really engaged us.  Definitely!

  • http://blog.edulang.com/ Brad Patterson

    “How could people have ever accepted learning from one person in one group of students in one room with the door closed to the rest of the world?”
    Wow… now that’s a quote.  I could play devil’s advocate and saying it all depends on the teacher, but you know what, keep those kind of pearls of wisdom a droppin’, J!

  • Sylvie_guinan

    Jason

    I can’t believe you already quoted yourself and I repeated it…

    Brad, what would you get if you crossed English Addicts with Eduglogster?

    Students would become interactive journalists – making posters out of news reports – that ONE idea could spark off hundreds of projects – such fun for children!!

  • Sylvie_guinan

    Online teachers are still real, aren’t they?

  • Sylvie_guinan

    Blended is nice for children though – very special.

  • http://blog.edulang.com/ Brad Patterson

    Like the way you think, Sylvia.  Look forward to hearing more from you soon ;-)

  • Jason Levine

    Right on, Brad. I agree that it all depends on the teacher! And those teachers who are able to do magical things on their own with one group of students behind a closed door will make the world their classroom; and the majority of students out there, those who could not gain access to that magic, will be able to do so.

  • Deirdre

    Optimistic!  At the moment everyone seems to be trying to find the cheapest way to give lessons.  In my opinion, teachers will have to adapt with whatever is decided as usual.

  • http://www.getintoenglish.com/ David

    I definitely think it’s great discussion on this site and I also checked out ‘the future of language schools.’ 

    I think no one’s come up with a highly profitable and popular model that’s better than the language school. Though someone will, as the demand for what we do is too strong. 

    If I use Prague (my present town) as an example: private language schools are all over the place, some closing down, and the present model is based on price-cutting. Only the British Council seems to be keeping its prices where they are. So will this lead to a closure of the British Council, as Czechs are loathe to pay more? How will the other schools be able to survive if they have such low margins, such low course fees, paying teachers who are also getting lower salaries? Well, whoever can create the next business model for this will be a pioneer, and an extremely successful one at that. 

  • http://blog.edulang.com/ Brad Patterson

    I can see where you’re coming from, Deirdre.  At the same time, I’ve always been a bit of a rebel in administrative situations where I was told to ‘adapt’ or do one way or another.  Things will change, but so will our opportunities.  If we stay passionate and open to what’s out there, there are almost always exciting directions to take.

    Cheers 4 the dialogue, Brad

  • http://blog.edulang.com/ Brad Patterson

    You’ve hit it dead-on.  DEMAND, and above all for English language learning.

    Pricing is of course a huge part.  People will pay nothing if the market allows them but the market can’t afford that, so it’ll balance itself and as always there’ll be an evolution.  Maybe it’s that famous saying… “you get what you pay for”… but then I wonder how that works with our pay what you want philosophy… hmmm… 

    Always glad to have your 2 cents, David!

  • Gomommyvanny

    There will always be people who learn by doing and will prefer to have a physical presence. As for children, they will always need a classroom environment and the parents will demand it. So technology does have a limit when people draw that line.

  • http://blog.edulang.com/ Brad Patterson

    Thanks for stopping by.

    I agree that there are many reasons why physical learning environments will continue very strongly as virtual ones grow as well.  Indeed, we are the ones who draw the lines, though each of us draws them quite differently, and that, to me, is a wonderful thing. ;-)

  • http://joaquinls.wordpress.com/2012/05/26/are-teachers-a-disappearing-profession/ Are teachers a disappearing profession… ? « E-learning y Pedagogía

    [...] on http://www.edulang.com Valora esto:Compartir estoFacebookLinkedInTwitterImprimirCorreo electrónicoMe gusta:Me gustaSé el [...]

  • naomi epstein

    The computer will never be able to give the student a warm smile, a compliment on something nice, a reminder how last time he/ she felt something was difficult it was overcome. Most importantly the computer will never be able to show the student that we believe in his/her ability to learn!
    Great tools for your toolbox, but most of us need the human touch!
    Naomi

  • http://twitter.com/epicenterone Aaron Nelson

    Totally and completely agree with you Brad. Teacher 2.0 (nice definition!) is here, and teachers need to get on board.  Teacher as coach is how I too see the future of teaching, but I highly doubt teachers will vanish. How we interact with students, yes. That will and is changing, but I feel that we’ll always need flesh and blood to come along side to help us learn and grow. My two cents. :)  

  • http://www.scoop.it/t/francesc-farre/p/1849790643/are-teachers-a-disappearing-profession Are teachers a disappearing profession… ? | TIC – Recull de consells i recursos | Scoop.it

    [...] background-position: 50% 0px ; background-color:#222222; background-repeat : no-repeat; } http://www.edulang.com – Today, 12:12 [...]

  • http://blog.edulang.com/ Brad Patterson

    Thanks for the two cents, Aaron!

    The “flesh and blood” sentiment, the “human smile” feeling, many have said that and I of course agree.  It is programmed in us as humans that presence, real warm presence makes a difference.  

  • http://blog.edulang.com/ Brad Patterson

    Hey Naomi ;-)

    Yes, just as Aaron said there are some things that we can never foresee computers being able to do, unless certain science fiction books/films come true.  Either way, there is almost always a need for community in whatever it is that we do, and the teacher/leader/coach role in that community is very important.

  • http://www.scoop.it/t/speak-to-the-future/p/1840711296/are-teachers-a-disappearing-profession-a-journee-in-language Are teachers a disappearing profession… ? | A journée in language. | Speak to the future | Scoop.it

    [...] background-position: 50% 0px ; background-color:#222222; background-repeat : no-repeat; } http://www.edulang.com – Today, 3:23 [...]

  • http://www.edulang.com/blog/read-into-the-future-will-you-be-teaching-online-in-2020/ READ INTO THE FUTURE: Will you be teaching online in 2020? | A journée in language.

    [...] week the post on the future of the teaching profession generated some great [...]